I thought fans of the course might enjoy this quick flyover. When I was there in July, the place was very firm and fast and just about the most fun you could have on a golf course this side of Scotland.
MUIRFIELD
I had obviously heard great things about this course. One friend who has traveled all over chooses it as his favorite in the world. While I would not go that far, I do believe that it is one of the best I have had the pleasure of playing and easily in the world top 10. I think it has more in common with Shinnecock than the other links courses I played on the trip. The fairways are relatively flat and have very little rumple or small scale contour. The course is very fair which is not a prerequisite for me to like a course, and in fact I often find fair boring and mundane. Where Muirfield shines is the routing. It takes advantage of every aspect of the property and flows seamlessly – one good hole after another.
When you combine the course with the experience – four ball in the AM, an amazing lunch with a few Kummels, and then an foursomes match in the afternoon – and the result is one of the most enjoyable days in my golfing life.
Long Time…. No Blog
Its been a while. I have been working very hard on starting a new business and have had no time to update the website. It is my hope in the coming months to get back in the habit of updating the site. I will start with some photos and comments from a recent trip to Scotland with Murray International Golf. Cameron Murray, owner of the company, is a friend and he does an amazing job of putting together an itinerary and making sure things go smoothly. I can not recommend his services more highly.
Stay tuned for Muirfield…
MACH DUNES- THE DMK TAPES III
In this third and final part of my interview with David McLay Kidd about Mach Dunes (part 1 and part 2, here), the architect refutes one of my and others’ main criticisms of the course- an unwieldy routing with lots of blind shots and long transitions between greens and tees. It was my thought that if David and his team had compacted the routing at Mach Dunes and created a shorter course (7,200 yards was about the yardage from the tips) that wandered over less of the site, than maybe the environmentalists would have been more willing to make a few concessions and allow slightly more grading in the affected areas, resulting in a more playable and walkable course.
David refutes this by saying that he believed that they would look at it in the complete opposite way, that making the affected areas more compact would increase the overall degradation of the natural environment of the site. He also defends the length by saying that Tom Doak has made building shorter courses “half trendy” and he was trying to build something that would still be a challenge 100 years from now and was different from its 6,400 yard neighbor. If only David was accurate in saying that a trend was developing around shorter courses golf would be in a much better and more sustainable place. (Video after the jump).
AERIALS GALORE
Last winter I began a golf course archiving project that originated while I was trying to create a detailed image of the Yale course from the 1934 Connecticut statewide aerial survey. I was able to create a high-res file from images on the Connecticut state library’s website by stitching together 144 images into a .tif file that could print in a large poster size. I did the same for CC of Fairfield, where I spent most of middle to late teens caddying and working in the pro shop when I wasn’t mostly playing the course. (Unfortunately, the present course has lost much of the routing that appears in the 1934 photo.) And then I assembled one of Brooklawn CC where we played our high school matches for Fairfield High…and eventually I put together files for 23 courses from that one aerial survey. That 1934 April snap-shot reflects an impressive collection of work from Golden Age architects: Walter Travis, Donald Ross, Devereux Emmet, A.W. Tillinghast, Seth Raynor, C.B. Macdonald, Charles Banks, Robert White, Willie Park, Tom Bendelow, etc. In most cases, the aerials show these courses in their “as-built” conditions. By then, very few had been modified much from their original designs.
There is a very attractive texture to the black-and-white original images taken by Fairchild Aerial Survey Company. The large film format produced a richness image than any of the subsequent surveys during the next 60/70-plus years. Aside from using these images as archival blue-prints, the aerial perspective renders the delineation of fairways and greens as a form of land art. Some courses do this better than others, but the holes on Blind Brook, Wee Burn and Shennecossett in particular, appear like a school of wales, or paramecium in a petri dish, or sometimes I see submarines. Check them out before you think I’m crazy or hallucinating.
The 1934 images also show a Connecticut prior to a suburban sprawl. Other than Bridgeport, New Haven, Waterbury and Hartford, the state was positively rural, linked by small villages along the Soun
d and rural farming communities up north. There were no major highways of any kind and the courses along the coast, like Longshore, Shorehaven, Madison, Shennecossett and CC of Fairfield pre-date any development of density.
I was also able to find other aerials of the Yale course over the years from the same perspective: 1951, ‘65, ‘70, ‘86, ‘91, ‘95, ‘04 and ‘08. (Note to viewers, I did not re-label the Yale prints with any titles other than credit to the photographers. There’s also a second image of New Haven CC from 1965 that immediately follows it in the queue. That second one doesn’t have name, city either.)
This past December I downloaded another dozen Macdonald and Raynor courses–the two who designed the Yale course–from the US Geological Survey’s website, where they exist as part of the public domain. I was able to get very clear images of National Golf Links, Fishers Island, Westhampton, Creek, Piping Rock, Shoreacres, Chicago Golf Club, Mountain Lake, Yeamans Hall, CC of Charleston, Camargo, Fox Chapel, etc. About 36 of the 45 have been printed and are being framed in time for an exhibit in a small gallery in Silliman College in New Haven called Maya’s Room. (Silliman is one of the 12 residential colleges at Yale.) It will run for one week beginning this Friday evening. Some of the items have been sold and others have been purchased and donated to the clubhouse at the Yale course (and indoor golf team room on campus) where they will hang permanently. I know it’s unlikely many of you can make it to New Haven next week, so here’s the link to all 45 aerials on Picasa. These proofs have been downsized so they don’t really do the final, high res prints justice. Anyway, they make for an interesting set, and the Yale course through the years helps us track all the changes and recent restoration work by Scott Ramsay.
http://picasaweb.google.com/colinsheehan/GolfCourseAerials?feat=directlink
If you have any interest in purchasing any of these posters please email me at colinsheehan@gmail.com.
MACH DUNES- THE DMK TAPES II
This is the second part of my lengthy discussion with David McLay Kidd about his new course Mach Dunes in Scotland (Part One, here). One aspect of Kidd’s perspective on the course that I really respect is his bravery to put a product out there that he and the rest of the team knows has flaws. As he tells me, he wants the course to be judged on what it will become in fifty years when it has had a chance to evolve through grow in, management and environmentally sensitive alterations and not in one snap shot on opening day. You don’t hear an architect say this very often because it is sign of his lack of control. It is also show of humility that is often wanting in today’s top architects. (Video and Interview after the jump) Continue reading →
SAGEBRUSH
Sagebrush was on my short list of places I wanted to get to this year, but after seeing this video, it has jumped to the top of my list. I spoke with Richard Zokol this afternoon and he let me know that USGA is going to conduct a case study on Sagebrush’s firm and fast conditions. As another storm rolls into DC, it’s stuff like this that really feeds the day dreams.
MACH DUNES- THE DMK TAPES
Mach Dunes opened in July of this past year at roughly the same time as Castle Stuart to the north. Neither is in the heart of Scottish golf touring area and so few if any have played them both. I did make it out to the Mull of Kintyre a few weeks before it opened and I had been warned in an email from architect David McLay Kidd, to, “just remember it’s a work in progress not a Fazio-esque insta-course!” I took this to heart and did not worry about conditioning as I played my way around. (Video and Interview with DMK after the jump) Continue reading →








